“It’s just an obscure legal theory from the 70’s. No one’s teaching it in schools anyway, so don’t get your knickers in a wad.” Says the guy in a Mao Zedong T-shirt. It’s a pack of lies, of course. (In case you haven’t read many Omnipotentblogs, it may or may not be evident I have a minor obsession with the communists who may or may not be sneaking into my room at night to steal my life force.)
What is CRT, anyway? Like most academic
theories, the descriptions
are impenetrable gobbledygook. Since academics love expansive and complicated
models, there are a number of tenets to deconstruct.
·
Systemic vs. Individual: Discrimination may
be bigotry, but it is not racism. Racism is one group’s power over and
oppression of racial minorities. Hence, People of Color (POC’s) may be bigoted, but only whites
can be racist.
·
Rigid heuristic: “Critical” means “to
criticize” or interpret. It is a lens through which all inequity is focused.
·
Anti-Democracy: Critical race theorists
believe that “political liberalism is incapable of adequately addressing
fundamental problems of injustice.” Its emphasis on color blind, equitable
treatment under the law renders it capable of recognizing only the most overt
and obvious racist practices, not those that are “indirect, subtle, or
systemic.”
·
Revolution: CRT literature denigrates
incremental or reformist approaches. The problem is dire and systemic. The
solution must be swift and comprehensive.
·
“White Privilege”: All whites, even poor
ones, benefit from a system of inherent advantage.
·
“Microaggressions”: Any solution to racial
inequity must tackle the subtler aspects of racism, often reflected by small,
unintentional slights or insults. POC’s and white allies must be acutely aware
of, and call out such offenses.
·
“Material Determinism”: Legal actions, whether advances or setbacks
for POC’s always end in helping privileged elites maintain their power.
·
“Voice of Color”: Only POC’s are qualified
to speak on behalf of their group about racism.
·
Race as social construct: Race is not a
true scientific category (sounds conservative). Racial categories exist for
the purpose of oppressing and exploiting people of
color. The very existence of racial categories signifies and is evidence of
oppression and exploitation.
·
“Equity”: “…the state, quality or ideal of
being just,
impartial and fair.” “Distributional
equity is…the
fair distribution of benefits and burdens across all segments of a
community, prioritizing those with highest need.”
·
“Anti-racism”: Moral adequacy necessitates
actively fighting the system. There is no such thing as a non-racist; There are
only anti-racists and racists.
Lettuce unpack this: CRT, by definition, says that America
is completely saturated in racism, the crisis of all crises, that liberal
democracy is wholly incapable of defeating it, that all inequity should be
viewed through the lens of oppression, that absolute parity of all racial and
other oppressed groups is the goal of any just society, that only POC’s are truly
qualified to even comment about racism, that their experiences of abuse are to
be accepted without challenge, that all whites are collectively guilty of this
abuse, and to be a decent person, you must actively work to tear down the current
system, i.e. capitalism and democracy.
CRT demands a blind acceptance of the sacrosanct “lived experiences” of POC’s. A
white person’s job is to empty the mind, shut up, and listen. There can be no give-and-take, no back-and-forth
required for an authentic relationship. Though feelings determine
reality, it really is only certain kinds of feelings since every human
interaction is seen through the lens of power and domination. CRT is a predetermined
ordering of priorities. In, “No, The Woke Won’t Debate You. Here’s Why”, the author explains that the woke view every challenge
raised as being steeped in a racist framework, so why engage at all? CRT is
a tautology, a circular logic where the theory is its own proof. When the
answer to every question is pre-ordained, you have abrogated reason. You have
banished thought itself.
CRT, derived from “Critical Theory”, is explicitly Marxist. It merely substitutes class for race. Carnival
barker Ibram Kendi said,
“Racism and capitalism are “conjoined” twins that will die together…To be anti-racist is to be anti-capitalist,”
for you cannot have markets without inequity. Ironically, the best anti-1619 Project piece I read was from the World Socialist Website. They share the goals of CRT, but they hate it because they believe class is more important
than race. (Fist bump to the World Socialists. Strange times.)
CRT corrals humanity into two camps: Oppressed and
Oppressors. It infantilizes POC’s as victims, and pigeonholes them into a monochromatic block, as if
Tibetans, Nigerians, and Mexicans are the same. It does the same to whites.
Since all whites, kind-hearted or not, benefit from the current arrangement, their
“privilege” brands them as oppressor. But white devils should take heart because
they are not individually guilty, just collectively. Despising color-blindness, advocates want
whites to think of themselves as white. Have they really thought this through?
As one older
gentleman put it, “They want to separate us into tribes.
So okay, I’ll stand with my tribe.”
For the Woke, mere inequity is proof of system racism.
Kendi argues if we truly say all races are equal, there can be no other
explanation for differences. Stunningly simplistic, he makes culture irrelevant.
A simple thought experiment shatters the juvenile logic. Imagine two
identical families of color. One discusses sports at the dinner table while the
other discusses school, science, and history. Or two other families where one says
America is racist and oppressive, and the other tells their children they are
the masters of their destiny.
The implicit message of CRT is dehumanizing and
disempowering. Collectivizing identity leads to the crabs in a bucket
phenomenon: When one tries to crawl out, the others pull him back in. Spiritually
toxic, it destroys moral agency
and discourages the development of virtue. For if the problem is America and not you, why break your back
to build habits of honesty, patience, and perseverance? CRT’s solution is to
redistribute wealth, but no one appreciates what they haven’t earned. See “Ruined lottery winners”. Is anything expected of POC’s at all? Without
responsibility, there is no freedom. Rob a man of accountability, and you rob
him of life itself.
The Black Hills of South Dakota??? Might as well be “The N___r Hills.”
I despise CRT because it makes us hate each other. By
design. How can it not be explicitly racist when it makes grand assumptions
about unique human beings based on skin color? If you study revolutions, you
will see that, even now, America is probably too stable to suffer such calamity.
But the Marxist wankers in this country sure are trying. And when my friend’s nine-year-old son comes
home from school one day and says he wishes he wasn’t white, we know their plan
is working. They will probably fail, but before they do, they will cover
the land in a blanket of misery. God help us.
No comments:
Post a Comment